It is interesting when looking at creation myths the role that women have played in these stories. In some cultures women are a positive force; life givers not only in the sense of giving birth to children but also of creating the world and its inhabitants. For example in Aboriginal mythology the first woman was called Waramurungundi and she was celebrated as the woman who gave birth to all living things and taught language to the Australian people. On the other hand the introduction of women can be a negative concept, an explanation for the problems of the world; Christianity has long blamed women for the “fall of man”. What interests me is why different myths portray women in different ways and how they are portrayed.
From the reading I have done I have found that the representation of women differs due to the type of civilization (agrarian, mercantile, nomadic etc) but also the role of women in that civilization’s society. The Wyandot (or Huron) people of America were farmers who added to their diet by fishing and hunting. They held the world around them and its animals in high regard and moved every decade or so to new, more fertile land. Whilst the men did most of the hunting and fishing it was the women who did most of the farming. The importance of women is reflected in their creation myth which has a woman falling from the sky into the water below. She then, with the aid of animals that lived in the water, built the world on the back of a turtle. Without the help of a man the woman had twin sons, one of whom killed her as she gave birth to him and when she was buried all the plants needed for life grew from her grave, including maize which grew from her chest. In the Americas maize was the key crop that was grown due to it being a hardy and dependable crop; it is a crop that has been celebrated by different cultures from the Mayans to the Moche. In fact in Mayan oral traditions maize is often shown as a woman. With this myth it is important to note that not only did a woman create the world, give birth to the sons that populated the world with humans and other animals (some of which were of use to the humans) but also she gave them maize. She is shown as the provider because of the female role of providing the harvested crops from the farmed land.
In some other civilizations women were not held in such high regard and had less power and status as men did, which is reflected in their myths. In the myth Gilgamesh, the Sumerian culture showed women to be a hindrance or as a temptress. The women are either untrustworthy, such as Ishtar the goddess of love who slept with and broke the hearts of many men, or when faced with a challenge weak and needy; Ishtar is confronted by Gilgamesh and she turns to the Bull of Heaven (a powerful male character) to defend her. In Sumerian society women had next to no power outside of their role in the family and in law were dominated by men.
This is a similar image to how Pandora is portrayed in the myth of Prometheus. Hesiod talks of Pandora and women in general in both Works and Days and Theogony. She seems to have been created in retaliation for Prometheus’ theft of fire. Zeus and the other gods create her to punish men, and due to his love of men also punish Prometheus. The descriptions of Pandora are that she is beautiful and finely adorned but also that she is malevolent within. She punishes men because men are attracted to her beauty but she will cause them nothing but problems due to her “shameless mind” (Works and Days, lines 65-70). This draws a good comparison with the sacrificial meat that Prometheus used to trick Zeus in the first place. The portion that Zeus picked was bones covered by skin; it looked good on the outside but was useless and undesirable within. Pandora is shown in the same way, a beautiful woman with inherent evil inside.
Men were already in existence when Pandora was created by the gods giving her a degree of separation from men, which reinforces the separation of men and women in Greek life. Women in ancient Greece spent most of their lives indoors at home dealing with family and domestic responsibilities. Men would go out, working, trading or farming for example while women remained at home. Women were kept at home to protect them and also to guard them from meeting other men who, in the minds of ancient Greek men, would easily seduce the women and therefore potentially disrupt the flow of inheritance by illegitimate children. This opinion of women being weaker and deceitful stems from Pandora. Hesiod’s account of Pandora warns men of the dangers of women, that women are trouble who cause mischief and sorrow for men.
In Theogany, Hesiod demonstrates this sorrow for men in the comparison of women and bees in a hive. He talks of women as if they are bees who stay in the hive and feed off the hard work of the male bees. He mentions the bees in the hive piling “the toil of others in their own bellies”. Hesiod is drawing on the opinion that women did not work hard in their domestic duties but lazed around while the men did all the hard work in the fields. When he writes about the women piling the toil into their bellies he is alluding to women eating the produce the men have harvested. He says it as though women are eating the men’s hard work for their own gain and greediness but when drawing the food into their own bellies the women would also be feeding a child in their bellies if they were pregnant, which without contraception would be a fair amount of the time. Hesiod is very quick to portray women as being selfish but there is no mention of the hard work it is to run a home, a family, be pregnant or actually give birth. He talks of how wives, and the children they produce, are useful in your old age to look after you (a rare positive side to a woman) but not the actual process by which those children appear. Of course being a farmer in a hot place like Greece must have been incredibly hard work but I am sure that more women have died of childbirth than men in a field with a plough.
In this respect it is a very selective opinion of women and their function in life. It is though Hesiod and men in general were displeased with their lives and were looking for a scape-goat. Not only is this opinion a chance to make women inferior to men but it takes the responsibility for an unsatisfactory life away from the man, even though he is ignoring the fact that without a wife and children he would still have to work to feed, clothe and house himself. Zeus gives men a clever punishment with the gift of Pandora and all her female descendants. By giving men a choice of being alone without a wife and being in “unrelenting pain” (Theogany line 611) with one he is showing his superiority and that despite Prometheus’ best efforts it is impossible to outsmart him as whatever you do he is punishing you.
Hesiod has a few inconsistencies in both his accounts of this myth. In Theogany and Works and Days Hesiod calls Prometheus cunning and clever while Pandora is deceitful and knavish. These adjectives have similar meanings but Prometheus’ tricks are seen as good and Pandora’s mistakes as bad. This may simply be because Pandora is the evil of the myth but also could reflect that male mistakes were seen less harshly than female ones. In lines 91-95 of Works and Days Hesiod says that Pandora ruined the world by releasing “harsh toil” on men when she opened the jar. But in lines 43-49 he says that Zeus concealed food which required no work to grow or harvest from men because of Prometheus’ trick with the sacrificial meat not a by-product of Pandora’s existence or her opening the jar. Now, of course, Pandora didn’t help matters with all the evils she let out but it wasn’t her fault in the first place. And from what I have read I haven’t seen that anyone told her not to open the jar. Prometheus warned his brother, Epimetheus, not to accept a gift from the gods but he doesn’t appeared to have rushed around and told anybody to leave the jar alone. Pandora was made in such a way that she was meant to be a punishment, she wasn’t meant to be a nice gift, if Prometheus was so smart then why didn’t he take the jar away so that only Epimetheus would have to deal with her “doglike mind”? If Pandora didn’t know what was in jar or the fact that it was evil then why wouldn’t she open it. It is the same with Eve and the forbidden fruit. God told Adam to leave the tree untouched and then he created Eve. No one ever told her to leave it alone so she didn’t. In this respect if we try to learn about a culture’s views on women by looking at their representation in myths then it seems here that men were angry at women for making mistakes that the men knew could happen but failed to communicate that to the women.
In this myth I think there are three male characters who are at fault a lot more than Pandora. Firstly, Prometheus for thinking he was cleverer than Zeus and not knowing his place or when to stop with the tricks and power-plays. If he had piped down then none of the following problems would have happened. Secondly, Epimetheus. He had been warned by his much smarter brother to not accept any gifts from the gods and he ignored that advice. If he had sent Pandora back then she would have languished about somewhere still with her jar and then men would have been fine and without the hassle of having or not having a wife. And finally Zeus, if he had punished Prometheus personally after the first trick rather than being sly and punishing Prometheus via man-kind then it would have been settled much more simply without all the collateral damage that left men with negative feelings about women for generations.
Hesiod
Theogony, Works and Days trans. M.L. West
Oxford, OUP, 1999
The Epic of Gilgamesh
Assyrian International News Agency
Books Online
"Huron Creation"
A Dictionary of Creation Myths.
David Adams Leeming and Margaret Adams Leeming.
Oxford University Press 2009 Oxford
24 October 2010
No comments:
Post a Comment